Irish Freedom Committee POW Dept. logo

CRISIS AT MAGHABERRY - ACTION REQUEST - Suggested Response

RESPONSES FROM NORTHERN IRELAND PRISONS SERVICE - Suggested Letter

Date: 05 30 03

Many of our supporters from across the United States have received offensive responses from the Northern Ireland Prisons Service, alleging that the policy of forced integration of republican prisoners alongside loyalists is designed to "reward the individual" and create "the safest prison regimes for both prisoners and staff".

Like many of you, we find these answers condescending and wholly unsatisfactory. We fail to understand how an atmosphere can be declared "safe" where republican prisoners are grossly outnumbered, routinely harassed, brutally attacked, and openly targeted for death. 

We encourage all of you to continue to lodge your complaints with the NIO and NIPS here: CRISIS AT MAGHABERRY

Republican prisoners at Maghaberry are being pushed to the brink of endurance, and they desperately need your help. Please don’t allow history to repeat itself!

If you have written to the Northern Ireland Prisons Service and/or Northern Ireland Office and have received a REPLY indicating that their forced integration policy at Maghaberry is for the good of the prisoner and that republican prisoners are being protected despite being housed on landings alongside loyalists who have issued death threats to them, please consider a SUGGESTED REPLY to these outright lies:

 

SAMPLE LETTER: A RESPONSE to NIO/NIPS REPLY

ATTN: Mark McCaffrey
Press & Communications Unit
Northern Ireland Prison Service


With all due respect, your reply here does not begin to address the ongoing violent physical danger these republican political prisoners are living under. I refer to several violent and brutal attacks against republican prisoners over the course of the past few years at Maghaberry Prison by the loyalist paramilitary prisoners you have elected to forcefully house them with:

MARCH 22, 2003: Republican prisoner JJ Connolly seriously burned with scalding water thrown at his face from loyalist cell 
APRIL 8, 2002: Republican prisoner Ciaran McLaughlin viciously attacked with an electric iron, suffering severe lacerations and contusions to his body and face in a totally unprovoked attack by loyalists. 
SEPTEMBER 4, 2001: Republican prisoner John Swift brutally attacked with an electric iron, leaving him near dead. John needed 17 staples to his head and 14 stitches to his face after the unprovoked attack by loyalist paramilitary prisoners, which also left him with a broken wrist. 
OCTOBER 31, 1999: Republican prisoner Tommy Crossan scalded in an unprovoked attack by loyalist paramilitary prisoners 

MANY, MANY OTHER ATTACKS against Remand prisoners have been recorded and go unreported out of genuine fear against further reprisals.

I am certain you will also be familiar with the PSNI police visits one year ago to republican prisoners at Maghaberry, warning them that death threats had been delivered against them by loyalist groups inside the prison. Knowing this, how does your policy of "treating the prisoners as individuals" explain your decision to place these men in alongside the same loyalist prisoners who have issued the death threats?? Is this how loyalist paramilitary prisoners are "rewarded for good behaviour"?

I am entirely unclear as to how this policy of forced integration amongst persons and organizations who do not even live in the same communities on the outside can subsequently provide for " the safest prison regimes for both prisoners and staff" at Maghaberry. Clearly this is not anywhere near the established definition of "safe" to house sworn enemies side by side in close quarters; particularly in the cases of the republican prisoners who are grossly outnumbered upon these landings, and, as we have clearly established, have already suffered a series of vicious attacks and are currently living under mass death threats.

Please explain to us how this policy could possibly "reward the individual". Your answers below are not remotely encouraging.

Sincerely;

(YOUR NAME/CITYT/STATE HERE)

-----Original Message-----
From: Northern Ireland Prison Service
Sent: Friday, May 30, 2003 5:08 AM
To: Irish Freedom Committee
Subject: Re: Appeal regarding Maghaberry Jail


To Irish Freedom Committee;

Thank you for your recent correspondence.

You seem to be labouring under a misapprehension.

All prisoners in Maghaberry, regardless of their perceived political
persuasion, are allowed to wear their own clothes and to associate freely
within their accommodation block.

With regard to separating prisoners who hold different political views, the
Northern Ireland Prison Service firmly believes that integration provides
for the safest prison regimes for both prisoners and staff and meets the
Service's obligations under the Human Rights Act.

Integration gives the Service the ability to treat prisoners as individuals
rather than as part of a group and means prisoners can be rewarded for good
behaviour thus giving each prisoner responsibility for his/her own actions.

A fundamental tenet of Prison Rules, which are enshrined in legislation and
have been the subject of democratic debate, is that all prisoners shall be
considered individually and that all prisoners committed by the Courts shall
be held safely and securely for the protection of the community and the
interests of justice.

When prisoners are segregated they act in a collective way which prevents
treating them as individuals and compromises their own and staff safety.

Independent reports into the Prison Service, ranging from the Hennessy
Report to the report by Lord Colville and, most recently, the HMCIP report
by Sir David Ramsbotham in 1998 arrived at the same conclusion.

Rest assured that the safety of staff and prisoners is of paramount
importance to the Northern Ireland Prison Service.

Thank you for your interest.

Mark McCaffrey
Press, Communications & Planning Unit

www.niprisonservice.gov.uk
info@niprisonservice.gov.uk

PLEASE NOTE: SAMPLE LETTER BELOW AVAILABLE FOR YOUR OWN USE HERE

----- Original Message -----
From: Irish Freedom Committee
To: "Ireland Prison Service Northern" <info@niprisonservice.gov.uk>
Sent: Thursday, May 29, 2003 5:16 PM
Subject: Appeal regarding Maghaberry Jail


> Dear Sirs and Mesdames,
>
> I urge you to improve conditions in your prisons by allowing republican
> prisoners to associate freely, wear their own clothes and be segregated
from
> loyalist prisoners by being given their own wing and facilities for
> recreation and independent work. Many of us here in Irish-America
remember,
> sadly and regretfully, the hunger strike a little more than twenty years
ago
> that needlessly cost the lives of ten men. Irish-Americans like me, and
the
> organizations we represent, do not want to see the situation in the
prisons
> there come to that again. We are very upset that it has been allowed to
get
> this dire already. Please do your best to listen to voices like mine and
> defuse this situation before it gets any worse.
>
> Sincerely yours,
>

> Irish Freedom Committee
>
>

BACK to CRISIS AT MAGHABERRY - ACTION REQUEST

Irish Freedom Committee POW Dept. logo